Dreamz made big moves when they counted to get him further in the game. However, that doesn’t take away from the fact that her game in this season just never could get off the ground. Jed Hildebrand 2.0! While in Samoa, Hantz did temper himself a little bit (not a lot mind you) to the point where he may have had a chance at winning. He takes the car, then at the final three, doesn't give immunity to Yau-Man and votes him out. He would go on and on talking about his relationship with god but does not care one bit about relationships with people around him. SO, instead of just writing a Top 10 or Top 20 list, though I reserve the right to do it in the future, I decided to highlight the worst player from each season. The guy did make good moves and form strong alliances in both seasons, his strange policies and ideology has always been his Achilles heel and can often times lead to some serious hypocrisy. As stated before, Keith adapted and started to make legitimately good moves near the end. Absolutely disgusting person. He's been a possibilty to be sent home every time he was at tribal council at one point, and towards the end he made a final two with every single girl in the top five. She had Sooo many chances to switch it up, but wanted so bad to be friends with the mean girls! But, overall, the guy just seemed to get on Survivor by being related to Russell, his entire personality was attached to his uncle, his entire legacy was to increase the Hantz legacy, and he followed along with Coach’s cockamamie scheming until it bit him in the butt. He never made it to the merge and become a jury. No I'm kidding of course, j'tia I'm sorry if you're reading this but most of the brains immunity challenges were lost primarily because of her. First off, he made the decision to give up his immunity necklace in the exact same manner as Erik Reichenbach and yet he still doesn’t get the derision that Erik gets for it because I guess his was in some sort of self righteous sense. Seriously, what did she even do? Say what you want about Francesca or Erik making blatantly stupid moves, Colton QUIT. There are a few posts, but for the most part all but a few of them to be wildly inaccurate and focus on players that people did not like as players, not on their strategy or their gameplay. In a season where almost all new players were nothing but a bunch of sheep, or simply had no idea how to play the game, this guy is the king of dumb players. Once again, I want to stress this was a high gameplay season so Stephen certainly shouldn’t be considered in the Top Ten for worst players. Natalie White and Mick Trimming were not able to deal with Ben for 8 days. Yeah, it sucks that James left with two immunity idols in his pocket. After HvV it was JT (and the rest of his tribe) for giving the hidden idol to another tribe without any knowledge of what it was going on there. One of the things that drives me nuts about moder survivor is the need for “big moves” which doesn’t come across as big moves anymore, it comes across as “flashy moves” that make a lot of noise but don’t really go anywhere. Instead of looking at simple numbers at the merge and after the medical evacuation of Joe Dowdle, all Timbira had to do was boot JT, Stephen, and Taj, three HUGE threats. The other dishonorable mention bounces to Crazy Dave Cruser who was… well crazy…. He then admits to it at Tribal Council like it isn’t that big of a deal while he is on the bottom of the alliance while dragging his friend, Jay Starrett, along with him. People like Grant and Ashley who are mediocre players and not even that likeable would have almost swept the votes over Rob and Phillip just due to how disliked they were, and Natalie couldn't even get 1. I think you need to end up on this list in some capacity. If he doesn't give up immunity to Albert he has a good shot at making the end. If the scenario was real, and there was no votes and nonsense- his fellow cast aways would have collectively hit him over the head, gutted him and used his flesh as bait for capturing food. She should have been gone in the first episode, He threatened to quit and said the only way he was going to stay was if the others fed him. The winner of the prize though, JP Calderon, earns the spot as worst player for being someone who legit had a chance to make good gameplay. Eh, I don’t know about that. Elizabeth was a strong competitor who ended up in a shitty goat to the slaughter situation at the merge that saw her unanimously ousted. Russell Hantz will never win the game because his entire game play does not rely on making good strategic decisions, it is to make good strategic decisions while being an absolute asshat every step of the way. This spot ALMOST went to Zane Knight, the first person voted out of the season for orchestrating his exit by taking himself from safe and secure to walking out first. But they have a slight problem on their hands. He literally says he is gay. But the two times he played saw him on the list for dubious reasons. Well, they can’t all be winners. Obviously, spoilers abound… She is pathetic, and she had the nerve to call Chase a goat when she was the biggest goat in the game by a huge margin. Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers: Mike Zahalsky. 9. As such, Garrett easily wins the worst player for Survivor Cagayan. He called Baylor a brat whenever he was on the outs, which didn’t gain any trust and insured Natalie, Missy, and Baylor wouldn’t switch, and was considered to be too two faced to keep around. But during the merge he was just kind of “there.” He had a good gameplay decision to play a hidden immunity idol to keep him in the game. Flirting was another idiotic downfall of hers. Thailand was a fucking awful season and one of the worst parts is the cast which was just appalling to watch and to watch strategize. After Lex went ballistic about getting a single vote, when they booted their ally Clarence, and thinking that it was Kelly who did the voting everyone that wasn’t in that core four were seemingly on board with taking control of the game… Except Brandon. The guy formed a power couple showmance with Jessica “Figgy” Figueroa which, in truth, is not the worst as the show made it seem. For starters, I am going to say that John Carroll does not deserve a lot of credit for forming the voting block that he did with Robert, Tammy, Zoe, Paschal, and Neleh against the former Maaramu tribe. If she made it to the end- there would be NO votes for her, she denied Sash's Aferican roots, because he wasn't black enough for her (most African American have less then 80% African DNA & that comes from multiple countries, a little less then 20% European {mostly UK} & around 2% Asian/ Native American). On another point, it is very obvious that this guy is an actor. This season is high octane on gameplay so you had to bring your A Game for this one. No Russell didn’t deserve it in Samoa, he didn’t deserve it in Redemption Island, and he doesn’t deserve it here either. He flopped on his alpha guy alliance with Edgardo, Mookie, and Alex which saw him move even further in the game and he did make the tactical decision to keep his immunity necklace and reneg on the deal with Yau Man. To be the best player of all time, you have to not only be able to control others and get to the end, but also get the jury votes, which is a HUGE part of the game. A season can have multiple winners IF and ONLY IF their badness is non distinguishable that they both need to be highlighted. It was like watching a kid who stole something from a retail store swear to the cops he didn't- even after they show him a security tape of him doing it. These injuries can come from competitions, infections and vicious wounds, just to name a few. This gave Stephen and co. an opportunity to blindside Tyson because, in Coach and Tyson’s shared arrogance, they didn’t realize they had completely crapped on and rightfully pissed off the two girls Sierra and Erinn. Rupert Boneham also named favorite and least favorite players. I know some are right now saying why is Jeff being punished for a single mistake while Colby is forgiven for his single, more consequential mistake? But when her tribe did not receive her well in the opening, her strategy was just to continue to do what she did until they voted her out. All 3 parts he fail. (Returning players came from seasons 7, 9, 12, 13, 14, and 15). I think Russell Hantz is one of the worst players to play the game. He should not be this high up, honestly. But then I thought about Jeff Varner. Maybe help her digestive system, or at least a little protein for the woman.This guy shows us that a bipolar pathetic psychopath can sneak his way onto the show, not once but twice. She made it to Day 15 and was the 6th person voted out. I don't think she's the worst player but I think she's just very unaware of how her actions affect others. IF JEFF WON THE IMMUNITY CHALLENGE WHICH WAS STANDING ON A FUCKING BEAM than Ogakor was guaranteed a 0% chance of finding someone with a vote because Alicia, Rodger, Elisabeth, and Nick had no votes. 8th tribal council, Keith is voted out. He purposely aligned with the Tagi Alliance while trying his best to disassociate himself with the alliance as much as possible and to clear his conscience when the opposition was being picked off one at a time.