Hi again, On top of having touch has a display option, Lenovo's workstation ⦠So overall, 4 motherboards for the x1e and the p1 (2 each) and all 4 have the same coil whine and its independent of the cpu's and gpus installed. This is after some tweaking with ThrottleStop including undervolting and disabling turbo on battery, however, so expect around 6 hours if you are not into tinkering. On a wall USB-C charger you'll get enough power to keep the laptop running, but not to charge the battery. Lenovo's datasheet lists five different Intel processors for the ThinkPad P1 Gen 2: the Core i5-9400H, the Core i7-9750H, the Core i7-9850H, and the Xeon E-2276M. I feel the touch pad is too small and registers palms as misclicks too often. I've owned it for 7 months and seem to have won the QC lottery for the most part; no coil whine or backlight bleed for me. The technician replaced the mid-chassis a week ago, and the rattling disappeared completely. The TrackPoint, for which I got a custom-made soft-rim replacement (easier on the fingertip), is always a benefit on ThinkPads, as it allows one to type and mouse without ever removing the hands from the home row of keys. Probably the biggest gripe I have with the P1 overall is its fingerprint scanner, which is a Synaptics SGX. But it's having heating problem while charging. Nothing special at all. I don't have a calibrator here, but having seen lots of screens, I think the contrast looks a bit better than 700:1 Lenovo's ThinkPad P1 Gen 3 Laptop includes a 135W Slim AC Adapter and an 80Wh lithium-ion polymer battery. (Image credit: Laptop Mag) 1. It seems to resonate with my experience. You can check in Settings > System > Display > Advanced display settings. :), June 19, 2019 at 9:15 pm. Since the bottom cover and the mid-chassis are now completely new, and the problem is still slightly persistent, I have the feeling that it's either a design error of this model, or a quality control problem…, February 15, 2019 at 1:54 pm. July 3, 2019 at 11:48 am, I've been living in Asia for the last 13 years, so I just have bought white-label (unbranded basically) sleeves as I find them. The only thing that loses the P1 a maximum points score is the battery life. I hope to break this trend by logging my long-term experiences with certain machines as an end-user, and today we will do just that with the Lenovo ThinkPad P1 / X1 Extreme. In my case SG to USA, so it took DAYS for anything to happen because of the time difference. The coating seems exactly the same between Gen 1 and Gen 2, but superior to the somewhat flaky coating I observed on the X1 Carbon Gen 6. 362 x 246 x 18.4 mm (14.25" x 9.69" x 0.72") ... More Lenovo ThinkPad P1 Gen 3 configurations - 30 laptops. I had to wait two weeks for the new display and one month for one of the motherboards when the BIOS bricking epidemic was at it's height before Christmas. However, I would consider disabling speed step or using a speed step control software to lock it into performance mode while you are doing something that needs to be hiccup-free. In the end ill have the x1e loaner for like 6 months (as i travel for work) till they figure out whats going on. The trackpad is quite nice to use, as well, and it’s on par with the best Windows machines have to offer, such as the XPS 15. I could plug in a USB drive and just sit there and withing minutes it would disconnect, both in Windows and Linux btw. Definitely have backlight bleed. I'd guess if you're above 85 wpm or so it will hit you as often as it does me, March 12, 2019 at 2:09 am. July 26, 2019 at 2:52 am. The lowest it'll go will be around 45 C when you do absolutely nothing. 3. Please read and accept our website Terms and Privacy Policy to post a comment. I have tried registering different parts of my scanning finger and updating the software, but it is still an unreliable and frustrating biometrics device that achieves little of the improvement it was designed to provide. You can also subscribe without commenting. This is why I am actually reading this post - I am looking for peoples experience with P1 Gen 3, because it is the only one without nVidia. Top of the keyboard also heats up pretty quickly in just normal use. The palm rest on the right side of the chassis produced a "rattling" sound whenever I would tip on it with a finger or my palm. And yes, fully loaded. You'll get better thermals and performance for almost the same amount of money. Without any touching, in both windows and in booting (i.e. Based in Washington, D.C., Douglas Black is a veteran technology journalist, university lecturer, DJ, and consultant. Latest word though is the noise is "normal" as long as its too loud… which is the most rubbish thing ive ever heard. Great productivity machine, can do some decent gaming on the side (but I'm no gamer, and this is NOT a gaming laptop), and excellent build quality. ⢠3-year (1-yr battery) depot service ThinkPad P1 Gen 3 PSREF Product Specifications Reference ThinkPad P1 Gen 3 - January 27 2021 4 of 6 As an Amazon Associate LaptopMedia earns from qualifying purchases. Touching the device may cause a disconnect as well. Original / Genuine Battery For LENOVO ThinkPad P1 Laptop 15.36V 5235mAh, 80Wh , 5.235Ah, High quality Battery For LENOVO ThinkPad P1 Laptop in usa battery stores, welcome order original ThinkPad P1 battery for LENOVO laptop, find genuine ThinkPad P1 battery here, choose long life Battery For LENOVO ThinkPad P1 Laptop in replacement-laptop-battery.com. While you have the case open for undervolting, I would also recommend removing the film covering the air vents or otherwise you'll want to wear headphones when the fans start spinning – the fan noise out-of-box isn't music to the ears. I've had this laptop for about 5 months and the screen has cracked. It’s a small thing, but it throws you off every time it happens. I heard the different graphic cards can make a difference. You aren’t going to find a laptop with better build quality, input, I/O, and overall performance anytime soon, in my opinion. Yeah i had international support but it kinda seems useless since you have to still deal with the original country and they deal with the 2nd country and it gets messy and painful. I got a replacement panel from AUO that seemed to have better properties than the one that came with the laptop, and I while I don't professionally edit visual media, I use Windows Dark Mode and find the black levels quite good. I'd say about 11-12 seconds, which includes my 3 seconds dual boot screen for my rescue partition. At least they didn’t pull a Dell and permanently throttle the GPU without telling anyone, though. If I did use the trackpad, I would prefer to have a second set of dedicated clickers at the bottom of it, but that’s a matter of taste. March 11, 2019 at 3:38 pm. I suspect it's a convection thing: the base of the laptop, made from an aluminium alloy, did get hot. I just read this: Lenovo ThinkPad P1 Gen 3, 15.6â FHD (1920 x 1080) IPS, Anti-Glare with Dolby Vision, HDR, 500 nits, Intel i7-10850H vPro 6 Cores, NVIDIA Quadro T1000, 32GB DDR4 RAM, 512GB NVMe SSD ,Win10Pro $1,655.00 $ 1,655 . Did you make any changes in bios? I almost tried a third time, requesting a different lot of motherboards, but unlikely they would include it even know how to get that done given the red tape. The p1 had xeon + quadro p2000, the x1e has i7 8750 + 1050ti+maxq. Use this: https://resplendence.com/latencymon, September 19, 2019 at 11:39 am, September 23, 2019 at 10:31 am, Great, thanks. The GPU will not terminate the processes until you force it to, the easiest way of which seems to be to go to the Device Manager then disable and enable the GPU. Of course, you might have to wait for the parts. not just a driver issue). I think the aftershock/mag 15 is really good for latency, based on Jarrod's tech's recent review of it. Yes — I was thinking of mentioning it but ended up not because it was so satisfactory. You'll need to do undervolting to about -140 mV and likely open the case and repaste the CPU to get better thermals. The first is the well-documented ThinkPad keyboard firmware bug, which still seems to affect both X, T, and P-series machines. On normal use it's not that noticeable, but compiling larger projects and on synthetic benchmarks you'll see ~20 % performance drop with Hyper-V enabled. July 26, 2019 at 8:15 am. It's light and the keyboard is great, but otherwise I don't feel it's very comfortable to use. LaptopMedia.com
Frustrating, but perhaps driver related and may eventually be fixed. The X1 Extreme Gen 2 makes use of the same soft-touch-coated carbon fiber and magnesium chassis from the previous generation. Andrei and I talk about our picks for best laptops of 2018. Battery. If its common to others then its ok – just annoying vs an actual problem. The screen I got (a replacement due to the original having uneven lighting) is really quite nice. They really come to your home and replace any part on premises. I don't know if I'm having a driver issue etc, but it takes about 30 seconds.. I worked on them until the last day, despite the issues. Odd that both happened with both of your P1s. The 180-degree hinge characteristic of ThinkPads, camera shutter, dedicated trackpad buttons, TrackPoint, weight, and overall ergonomics of the machine are things I appreciate on a daily basis, even after months of use. As an aside, can you suggest similar laptops to P1/X1e that don't have latency issues (for DAW work mainly). At this point, I have 2 final questions: Can you comment on the FHD screen quality – is the brightness ok at ~300nits? got damaged and is now turning loose. Then there's the aforementioned Hyper-V related throttling issue. My biggest issue is with the portability of the laptop. Had some issues with a USB-A port cutting out on a wireless dongle, but solved it by not allowing Windows to cut power to that port to save power (strangely, this was only the case for one of the two USB-A ports — no problems with the other one for the same dongle!). Just boxed then both up and said goodbye :( Honestly, it was hard to let them go. Your email address will not be published. I still haven't seen anyone do the latency test with P1 Gen 2. I play a lot of Killing Floor 2 (great game, by the way; it has evolved immeasurably since I bought it in early-access a few years ago) and the fans noise is only occasionally audible over the sound from the game, though it does rev up at times. If its common to other people then i need to just suck it up and accept they make coil whine.